RosterElf Logo
Manager and employees
Blog Post

Should You Become Friends With Your Employees?

4 min read · September 13, 2017 Myri Enolpe

Building strong employee relationships for better teamwork

Building strong relationships with employees is essential for a positive and productive workplace environment. A key part of being an effective leader is understanding and motivating your team, which often involves forming a personal connection. However, the question remains: can a boss truly be friends with their employees?

It’s natural to want to connect people on a personal level. But it’s important to recognise the fine line between being friendly and becoming friends. Maintaining this boundary ensures that professional roles and responsibilities are respected. This helps prevent potential issues like favouritism, conflicts of interest, or challenges in performance management.

The challenge lies in balancing genuine care for your employees with your managerial responsibilities. Strong relationships based on mutual respect and clear boundaries can lead to better team dynamics. But stepping too far into friendship territory can blur these lines. This can cause complications in leadership and business performance.

This article explores the risks of becoming too friendly with employees and why keeping a professional distance is crucial for effective leadership. A strong connection is vital to achieving workplace connectivity, where employees feel a sense of belonging and are motivated to perform well.

Manager and employee engaging in conversation to build strong workplace relationships and enhance collaboration

How favouritism impacts workplace relationships and performance

A significant challenge of becoming too friendly with employees is the potential for perceptions of favouritism. When a manager forms personal relationships with certain staff members, it can create the impression that those employees are receiving preferential treatment. This perception can be damaging. It undermines trust within the team and disrupts a fair, balanced work environment.

Favouritism can have serious consequences for team dynamics. When staff feel that certain individuals are treated more favourably, it can lead to resentment and dissatisfaction. This negativity often results in decreased morale. Employees may feel less motivated to perform at their best. Over time, this dissatisfaction can spread and affect the entire team’s productivity and business performance. As teams are encouraged to stay connected, workplace links should remain clear to avoid division.

The impact of favouritism extends beyond individual grievances. It can divide the team, cause a lack of collaboration, and break down communication. It also diminishes trust in leadership. Employees who feel sidelined or overlooked may disengage. This lowers their commitment to the company and can lead to higher turnover rates. Managers should foster a culture of inclusivity, encouraging members to build connections based on merit, not personal relationships.

To avoid favouritism, managers should:

  • Treat all employees equitably.
  • Base decisions on performance, not personal relationships.
  • Ensure open communication and clear, transparent policies.
  • Foster inclusivity, providing equal opportunities for all employees while maintaining clear boundaries in personal interactions.

This approach helps preserve trust and fairness, ensuring a motivated, high-performing team.

Team divided due to perceived favouritism in the workplace, impacting employee morale and productivity

Why putting business needs first is crucial for managers

In any business, prioritising the organisation’s needs over personal relationships is crucial. While building friendships with employees can be valuable, managers must remain focused on the company’s best interests, especially when making difficult decisions. A friendship can cloud a manager’s judgment, leading to choices that may not be in the company’s best interest.

When managers become too close with employees, personal feelings can unintentionally influence business decisions. For example, a manager may hesitate to address poor performance or make necessary staffing changes out of fear of damaging the friendship. Personal biases may also affect decisions regarding promotions, workload distribution, or even the strategic direction of the business. These decisions can have long-term negative effects on the company’s performance, culture, and growth. A strong sense of connection is essential to making clear business decisions.

A manager who prioritises friendship over business needs might overlook key issues such as underperformance or conflict among team members. This can lead to bigger problems down the line. For example, failing to address an employee’s persistent tardiness, despite knowing them personally, can create a ripple effect. Other employees may feel the behaviour is tolerated, leading to resentment.

To maintain a professional focus, managers should set clear boundaries between personal and work relationships. Decisions should always be made based on what benefits the business and its overall success. Regular self-reflection and consulting with other leaders or HR can help managers make objective, business-focused decisions. By consistently putting the company’s needs first, managers can lead more effectively and create a fair, unbiased work environment.

Manager prioritising business needs, focusing >
</div>
<h2 >
    Managing performance issues with professional boundaries
</h2>
<p >
    Providing feedback to employees is a critical part of a manager’s role. It becomes more challenging when personal feelings are involved. When a manager is friends with an employee, giving constructive criticism or addressing performance issues can feel uncomfortable. There is a risk of letting emotions cloud professional judgment. Despite these challenges, it’s essential for managers to separate personal relationships from performance evaluations to ensure fairness and objectivity.
</p>
<p >
    When performance issues arise, a manager must offer honest, clear feedback, regardless of personal connections. The difficulty lies in the potential fear of hurting a friendship or damaging rapport. However, avoiding these conversations can lead to unresolved problems. This can affect the employee’s development and the team’s overall performance. A lack of honest feedback can also signal to the rest of the team that standards are not consistently applied. This can undermine trust in leadership.
</p>
<p >
    Managers must balance empathy with professionalism. It’s important to understand and support employees, especially when they are facing personal challenges. But the business needs to remain the priority. Managers should communicate performance expectations clearly and be prepared to provide feedback that focuses on the individual’s work and growth, rather than their personal qualities. By staying focused on professional development, managers can encourage improvement without compromising the quality of the relationship.
</p>
<p >
    If difficult conversations are avoided, employees may not fully understand their areas for improvement, leading to stagnation. Worse, a manager who avoids addressing performance issues may inadvertently encourage a culture of complacency. Ultimately, performance <a href=management is essential for the growth of both employees and the business. Regular, objective feedback is crucial in helping employees reach their full potential while maintaining a healthy and productive work environment.

Manager giving constructive feedback to an employee, promoting growth and communication in the workplace

The risks of talking shop outside work hours

Work-life balance is essential for maintaining personal well-being and professional productivity. However, when managers form friendships with employees, work-related discussions often spill over into personal time. While staying connected with your team outside of the office can strengthen relationships, constantly talking about work can lead to burnout and negatively affect both managers and employees.

When work becomes the dominant topic of conversation outside of employee shift, it can prevent employees from fully disconnecting and recharging. Constantly discussing work-related issues in social settings may cause stress to escalate, making it difficult for individuals to switch off. For managers, this dynamic can blur the boundaries between personal and professional life. It leads to a sense of being “always on.” Employees may also feel pressured to stay engaged with work, diminishing their ability to unwind and rejuvenate.

The risk of burnout is a serious concern. Both managers and employees need the space to disconnect and focus on other aspects of their lives to remain productive and engaged at work. Excessive work talk outside of work hours can lead to frustration, lower morale, and even physical and emotional exhaustion over time.

To maintain a healthy work-life balance, managers should:

  • Set clear boundaries around work-related conversations outside the office.
  • Encourage employees to switch off and pursue their personal interests.
  • Foster a supportive and professional environment at work.
  • Engage in non-work-related conversations during social events to remind everyone of the importance of time away from work for well-being and long-term productivity.

Confidentiality risks with personal relationships at work

Confidentiality is essential for maintaining trust and integrity within any business. However, when managers develop close friendships with employees, the line between professional and personal boundaries can blur. This increases the risk of oversharing sensitive business information. It’s essential for leaders to maintain a high standard of discretion to protect both the company’s interests and its employees.

Discussing sensitive information in the workplace, focusing >
</div>
<p >
    Friendships with employees may lead to unintentional leaks of confidential information. A manager who feels comfortable with an employee may be more inclined to share details about upcoming business decisions, financial matters, or strategic plans. While the intent might not be malicious, these conversations can result in the spread of information that should remain private. Even well-meaning sharing can lead to serious consequences, especially if sensitive information reaches individuals outside of the intended circle, whether internally or externally.
</p>
<p >
    The potential consequences of these information leaks are far-reaching. For example, if an employee learns about a company’s upcoming mergers or layoffs, they may inadvertently share this information with others. This could lead to anxiety among the workforce or jeopardise negotiations. A breach of <a href=confidentiality can also damage the reputation of the business, erode trust with clients or stakeholders, and result in legal or financial repercussions.

To mitigate these risks, it’s vital for managers to uphold strict confidentiality standards, even when personal relationships are involved. They should be mindful of what they discuss with employees and ensure that sensitive information is shared only with those who have a legitimate need to know. Clear boundaries between personal relationships and professional responsibilities help safeguard both the business and its staff. This maintains a culture of trust, respect, and professionalism.

Maintaining professional boundaries for leadership success

Maintaining professional boundaries is essential for effective leadership and the long-term success of any business. While building strong, supportive relationships with employees is important, it’s crucial to ensure these connections don’t blur the lines between professional accountability and personal interactions. In the previous sections, we’ve discussed how favouritism, personal biases, performance issues, and confidentiality challenges can arise when managers become too friendly with employees. The key to preventing these problems lies in maintaining clear boundaries and a balanced approach to leadership.

To maintain professional boundaries while fostering positive relationships, managers should:

  • Set clear expectations for friendly yet professional conduct.
  • Keep communication focused on work-related topics.
  • Recognise the value of empathy but always balance it with objectivity, especially when making tough decisions.
  • Schedule regular check-ins with employees to discuss progress, challenges, and feedback in a structured, formal manner.
how to build strong work relationships, employee engagement, workplace friendships

Managers should also be aware of their own behaviour, being mindful of how their actions and language might be interpreted.

Lastly, it’s important for managers to regularly reassess their boundaries, especially as relationships evolve. If a line starts to blur, it’s essential to readjust and reestablish the right level of professionalism to avoid the negative effects discussed earlier. Maintaining this balance helps ensure that employees feel supported while the manager remains a fair, unbiased leader.

Book a demo

Important Notice

The information contained in this article is general in nature and you should consider whether the information is appropriate to your needs. Legal and other matters referred to in this article are of a general nature only and are based on RosterElf's interpretation of laws existing at the time and should not be relied on in place of professional advice.

RosterElf is not responsible for the content of any site owned by a third party that may be linked to this article and no warranty is made by us concerning the suitability, accuracy or timeliness of the content of any site that may be linked to this article.

RosterElf disclaims all liability (except for any liability which by law cannot be excluded) for any error, inaccuracy, or omission from the information contained in this article and any loss or damage suffered by any person directly or indirectly through relying on this information.

Save hours on rostering and keep wage costs under budget

RosterElf is simple-to-use rostering software with small business prices, and local Aussie support.

Start free trial
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Rostering and Payroll Software Questions? We have the answers.

  • Maintaining boundaries ensures that professional roles are respected, preventing issues like favouritism, conflicts of interest, and compromised leadership decisions. It fosters a fair and productive work environment.

  • Overly close relationships can create perceptions of favouritism, disrupt trust, and lower morale, which ultimately impact team collaboration and productivity.

  • Work discussions outside office hours can lead to burnout, blurred personal and professional boundaries, and reduced ability to disconnect, impacting long-term productivity.

  • Managers can avoid favouritism by treating all employees equitably, basing decisions on performance, and maintaining transparency in communication and policies.

  • Personal relationships can make it uncomfortable for managers to provide honest feedback, potentially leading to unresolved issues that affect team performance.

  • Favouritism undermines trust and fairness, which can lead to disengagement, dissatisfaction, and higher employee turnover rates.

  • Clear boundaries help maintain objectivity, ensure fairness, and support a productive environment where employees feel valued and respected.

  • Maintaining confidentiality protects sensitive business information, preserves trust within the organisation, and safeguards its reputation.

Newsletter

Want tips on how to manage your staff better?

Subscribe to our newsletter and get a weekly tip straight to your inbox.